AlephBeta Logo
  • Home
  • Patron Circle
My List
Your list is waiting
Add Torah lessons you want to reflect on, revisit, or binge later.
Upgrade to All Access

Unlock all videos, transcripts, and study materials.

Start Free Trial
AlephBeta Logo

Stay Connected

Follow Aleph Beta on social media

InstagramTikTokFacebookYouTubePodcastsSpotify

About Us

  • About
  • Careers
  • Weekly Parsha

Our Team

  • Team

Get Help

  • Contact

Support Us

  • Subscribe
  • Educators
  • Shop
  • Donate
AlephBeta Logo

A Nonprofit Media Company helping people closely read the Torah to discover its beauty, meaning and relevance

Cookies Policy
Legal Terms
Privacy Policy

© 2026 Aleph Beta. All rights reserved.

HomeSearchProfile
Back

The Good Spies: How Negative Character Traits Can Become Positive

The Real Heroism Of Caleb And Joshua



Do you know the story about the spies? Moses sends twelve men on a mission to spy out the land of Israel. They come back bearing a bad report. “Scary people live there! The land devours its inhabitants! We’ll never be able to conquer it.” The people overreact, and God decrees that they should wander in the desert for 40 years.

Now, you may remember that not all of the spies were guilty. Two of them – Caleb and Joshua – tried to speak up. They tried to defend the land of Israel, to remind the people that it’s a beautiful land, a land promised to them by God, and that it was within their power to conquer it! 

It must have taken a lot of courage for them to speak up like that, and their little speech was no doubt stirring… but would you say that Caleb and Joshua were heroes? Because – reality check – no one actually listened to them. As soon as they finished talking, the people tried to stone them to death! They didn’t change anybody’s minds. God still punished the people. Their act of courage didn’t have any effect at all.

Or did it? It turns out that Caleb and Joshua did accomplish something on that day. No, they didn’t manage to change the people’s minds, they didn’t manage to forestall God’s punishment… but on that day, they reached back into Israelite history and corrected an egregious sin that hadn’t been spoken about about for hundreds of years.

What was the sin? And how did they correct it?

For Rabbi Fohrman's Pesach course which connects the sale of Joseph to the punishment of exile/slavery in Egypt: "How To Read The Haggadah"

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Spoiler alert!

For more videos that deal with the “redemption” of Judah and Joseph’s mistakes, see:

  • Joseph's... Groundhog Day?
  • The Far-Reaching Effects Of Judah’s Confrontation With Joseph
  • Family Feud: The Ominous Background To Esther’s Story
  1. The Real Heroism Of Caleb And Joshua
  2. Epilogue: The Real Heroism of Caleb and Joshua